Working with a book editor to revise a nonfiction manuscript

Working With a Book Editor: 3 Things New Authors Should Know

Of all the unfamiliar terms that come up for new authors during the process of writing and publishing their first book, I think “editor” has to be the most misunderstood. If you have ever said something like, “I’ll just have an editor fix it,” or “Do I even need to worry about an editor? Won’t my press give me one?” this is for you.

Even if you’re just thinking about starting a book, you have no doubt thought about editors. And if you’re confused about working with a book editor, that is not a fault of yours. “Editor” is an actually confusing term. Even those of us in the industry can sometimes misunderstand what we’re communicating about when we talk about what an editor does.

This is part one of a two-part series on the things I wish new authors knew about editors. Before we get into those misconceptions, we need to get clear on what we’re even talking about.

What Does Working With a Book Editor Actually Mean?

Almost always, in an industry context, we modify the word “editor” with something that helps us get more specific about what that person will actually do with a manuscript.

You might have heard terms like developmental editor, copy editor, line editor, or acquisitions editor. These are all types of editors. They are all correctly identified by that term, and at the same time, they do wildly different things.

One way to see how different these functions are is to look at the ways you might have heard me use “editor” when talking about Page & Podium’s services.

Book coaching and ongoing editing

Our Editor in Your Pocket program delivers what people often think of when they think of an editor. You submit your work, and we mark it up with suggestions: things you can strengthen, places you can pull your strengths further out, and things that might disrupt the reading experience.

We point out what is unclear. And yes, sometimes we point out what is correct or incorrect, although there are many more things that have no black-and-white right or wrong answer than you might expect.

While this is one-on-one editing, I also call it book coaching. In fact, that is typically how I refer to it with our clients. You are working with an editor who is editing your work, but you also have somebody walking you through the process and supporting you with the mindset issues that go along with writing.

All of those things can properly be part of an editor’s job.

Manuscript reviews and developmental editing

We also offer a Manuscript Review, which does not have a sexy, interesting title. It just is what it is.

We go through your finished manuscript and highlight both the strengths we want to make more consistent and the things that need your attention. We’re looking at whether this is a marketable book and a book your audience wants to read. Those things go together, but we can also think about them separately in terms of reach and engagement.

We don’t call this service “editing,” but a manuscript review is very similar to a developmental edit. If you’re deciding what kind of manuscript feedback you need, this is the kind that helps you understand the book as a whole.

Acquisitions editors, copy editors, and other roles

I typically try to do our manuscript reviews myself when I can, and I am also Page & Podium’s editor-in-chief. That is another type of editor entirely.

When a staff member does a manuscript review, they may also be functioning as what we might call an acquisitions editor: someone looking for books we can publish under our imprint. Sometimes we’re doing a copy edit or a line edit, where we’re working closely with the prose itself. That is another editorial function.

If you have felt confused by all of this, that is not a failing. It is a complex situation. Understanding which kind of support you need is an important foundation for working with a book editor.

1. You Can’t Just Hand Over Your Draft and Have an Editor “Fix It”

Hands down, this is the most common misconception I hear. I see it especially often in places like LinkedIn, where we tend to have more business-minded folks: you can simply write your draft and then hire an editor to fix it.

Y’all. It was actually difficult to think about where to start with this misconception because there are so many misleading assumptions baked into it.

Let me start with how it actually works when you come to an editor after finishing your draft.

In our manuscript review process, we ask authors to go through the manuscript and make it the strongest version they can put together on their own. Then I go through looking for high-level things: structure, pacing, and places where the book is not pulling the reader through.

I’m looking at whether the author has shared enough about themselves for me to get a sense of who they are. This is surprisingly common, by the way. Folks hold themselves back.

Do the stories make sense? Are the ideas unique and innovative? These are things you’ve probably thought about as you worked on your manuscript, but they can be really difficult to get right on the first try. There is a lot of nuance to work through between a first draft and a final manuscript.

And many of those things are not things I can do for you.

Your editor can’t supply your interior experience

Let’s take interiority as an example.

Particularly in memoir, I need more than what you did, what other people did, and what events happened. I need more than what a camera could capture. I also need to understand what those events meant to you at the time and what they mean to you now.

Most people focus on making the events clear. But often, because of the emotional challenge of digging back through our lives, we forget to weave in what we actually felt.

This is something I frequently push for, and it is absolutely something I cannot do for you.

I could take my best guess at what was happening in your mind. I see people use AI for this all the time. But the most truthful and meaningful answer for your reader will always come from your experience. That interior experience is part of what makes a memoir good.

Sometimes your response is what the audience would expect. Often, though, when I get into a manuscript with an author and we start digging through what they’re saying, there are actual discoveries. The author realizes things they had not understood before.

Can an editor help you “fix” your manuscript? Certainly. But the things that must come from you still need to come from you.

Grammar comes much later

I think one reason authors expect an editor to fix everything is that many new authors assume the place they need the most help is grammar.

I get this. Grammar gets pounded into our heads all through school.

Could an editor fix your grammar? Absolutely. That happens much later in the process, during copy editing. The issue is that most authors think it is the first thing they need when it is actually one of the last things they need.

If I’ve asked you to dial up the interiority, you need to do that first. As you add those passages to give me a sense of who you are and how you experienced an event, any grammar issues you have will show up there too.

It doesn’t make sense to fix the grammar when we know things need to change at a much higher level: your structure, flow, pacing, or whether your ideas are developed enough and consistent throughout the manuscript.

That is why I talk about making your large-scale revisions before moving into sentence-level editing. When you’re working with a book editor, you want the type of editing to match the stage your manuscript is actually in.

If you want someone else to revise it, you may need a ghostwriter

There is no shame in wanting to write a first draft and hand it over. But the person you hand it to may need to be a ghostwriter.

This is a service Page & Podium offers, and it is one of my favorites. We don’t take on a lot of ghostwriting clients because it is an intense engagement.

We recently worked with a client who had written her entire manuscript but realized she wanted it to look quite different on the page. She didn’t want to struggle through making those changes herself. It made more sense to hand over the manuscript and have someone help shape it the way she wanted.

That last bit is important. Even when we’re taking on a full revision, we start with a substantial period of development. We need to understand what you were trying to do.

Many of the same points about why an editor can’t simply fix everything are also true of ghostwriters. We need you involved. It is an involved process that takes time and is pretty pricey.

If your vision is to draft a manuscript, hand it to an editor, and have it come back finished, I want you to know that is an unrealistic expectation. That is very unlikely unless you’ve already gone through all the revision stages on your own, and it is a rare first-time author who can do that.

Expect to need a few different types of editing, and possibly ghostwriting as well. Being practical about how to revise your memoir will make it much easier to understand your next steps.

2. AI Editing Can Pull Your Manuscript in the Opposite Direction

The second thing I wish new authors knew about working with a book editor is that using AI to edit your manuscript can do something very different from what a human editor would do.

We recently did a series on AI and nonfiction writing. If you missed it, start with what writers need to understand about using AI to write a book. That gives you more information for making your own practical decisions about these tools.

Some of the confusion here comes from the same misconception we just discussed: new authors are often looking for the wrong thing when they first hire an editor. They’re looking for someone to fix their grammar.

AI can help identify grammar issues. We’ve been using automated tools that way for years, well before LLMs became accessible in our browsers.

But at that first stage of editing, grammar is not what you need most. You need someone who understands how books flow, how they communicate a message, and what they are trying to do.

An impressive answer isn’t necessarily a useful editorial answer

One tricky thing about AI is that we tend to assume its intellectual capacities will be structured the way a human’s would be.

When we hear about an LLM solving an impressive mathematical problem, we may assume it has comparable competence in other areas. But AI can be very good at one thing and very bad at another in ways that are difficult for us to anticipate.

It can also give us unusual responses that make it harder to notice the standardization happening elsewhere.

When we ask someone to look at our work in a larger context, we want them to identify its strengths and recognize what is unusual about it. An LLM might give us an insightful answer. It might also tell us to make the book more generic.

The problem is knowing which kind of advice we’ve received.

The folks I work with do not want their books to read just like everybody else’s. “Generic” is a bad word. Yet the suggestions that sound polished or professional can sometimes move a manuscript in exactly that direction. I’ve written more about how AI can flatten your writing.

A human editor should pull more of you into the book

A well-trained editor is looking for what makes your voice, perspective, ideas, and story both unique and recognizable enough to find an audience.

We want to pull you out more. We never want to push you into the background.

That is why we’re not focused on grammar for a long time. Grammar is not what will make your book sing.

When you’re working with a book editor, part of what you’re getting is discernment: someone who has studied, trained in editing, and read books for a living helping you understand which choices serve your particular manuscript.

New authors are still developing that discernment. That is completely understandable, but it makes it harder to evaluate whether an AI suggestion strengthens the book or simply standardizes it.

If grammar were what made your book sink or swim, this would be a different conversation. But particularly with a first, second, or even third draft, that is not usually the problem we need to solve.

3. Your Editor Will Find New Things in Every Round

Yes, we are going to find new and different things each time we look at your work.

A good editor also knows that, as we move a manuscript from draft to finalization, we are looking for excellent imperfection. Particularly with memoir, but really with any book, we will never reach a point where everything is perfect.

What would perfection even mean? That every reader cannot find a single thing wrong? That will never happen. The closest we could probably get would be a book so bland and unobjectionable that nobody complains, and I don’t know that we want that either.

Still, authors are sometimes surprised when new things come up in the second, third, fourth, or fifth round of editorial review. Sometimes decisions even get reversed.

I want to share an actual client example so you can get a sense of how working with a book editor might look.

First, the author drafts and revises

We’ve been working on a memoir called Less Than: A Memoir, by Maryann Hobbie, about her experience with a spinal cord injury and the PTSD that followed.

This book is complex and fascinating. I learned things about myself and my own brain from it, and I’m so excited for people to read it.

Maryann drafted her manuscript and revised it as best she could. At the time, she was part of our Memoir Method group program, so she had a book coach supporting her through the drafting process.

We now offer that kind of support one-on-one through Editor in Your Pocket. Not everybody gets coaching while drafting, and that is fine, although I highly encourage it. Support can make your manuscript stronger as you move into editing, which makes the whole process easier, more effective, and less expensive.

That is one reason it helps to understand what to expect when writing your first memoir before you get too far into the process.

Next comes a manuscript review

Once Maryann felt she had done what she could, she sent the manuscript for review. I read it and made notes about its strengths and weaknesses.

The thing that knocked me off my feet was the voice. It had a real authenticity, with touches of self-deprecating humor and sarcasm, but always an uplifting, grounded way of presenting herself.

I told her it read as effortless. It felt like sitting across from her at coffee, hearing her describe her experiences.

She wasn’t all the way there yet. In some parts, the voice sang. In others, we needed to pull it out further.

There were also issues we needed to tackle. As I mentioned earlier, many authors need more interiority, and that was true here. Some of the insights Maryann developed by pushing on that question were powerful. I truly believe they are going to change the conversation around disability studies.

When she received her manuscript review, she dug in and held herself accountable for working on difficult things. PTSD complicated that work, but she got support from us, her therapist, her friends and family, and the people around her.

Her manuscript became better and better.

Then we work through revision together

At that point, Page & Podium offered Maryann a book contract. We are selective about the books we publish under our imprint, but in my mind, there was no doubt this book was a fit.

Our publishing process included two months of revision coaching. That looks different for every author. With Maryann, we broke the book into four chunks. She revised a chunk, sent it to me, and I commented before we moved to the next one.

Then we did two full rounds in which I read the entire manuscript, gave feedback, and she combed through it again.

This is what I mean when I say working with a book editor involves going back and forth. The author continues making decisions and doing the work, with support.

A later read can reveal something new

When I looked at the manuscript for what I thought might be the final time, I noticed a couple of chapters weren’t flowing the way I wanted them to.

That had not stood out on the previous read. Why? Because as an author changes pieces of a manuscript, those changes affect how other pieces read.

As you refine a book, you may change something and sometimes change it back. That is okay. It can even be great, because your editor is right there with you, paying attention to how the whole book is coming together.

We want the reader to have an engaging experience that pushes them to reevaluate whatever message you are trying to communicate. Getting there takes more than checking off each comment once.

Working With a Book Editor Is a Partnership

Your editor should be on your team.

Yes, we will give you things to work on. You will revise them and bring them back. We work back and forth. But the way strong editors think about this, and the way all of us at Page & Podium think about it, is that we are your partner.

We are in there with you. We become deeply invested in the manuscript, and we want to help you make it strong.

If you would like us alongside you, start with a Manuscript Review. That is where Maryann began this part of her process, and we would love to see your manuscript.

There is nothing I love more than partnering with an author who is dedicated to making their book strong and driven by the need to help others: to make society more equitable, stronger, more communal, and a better place to live.

If you’re still unsure which kind of support you need, take our free Book Strategy Quiz. Answer 10 questions, and I’ll send you your next step along with a custom podcast playlist to help you move forward.

Happy writing.

Share This Post

Picture of Amanda Edgar

Amanda Edgar

Dr. Amanda Nell Edgar is an award-winning author, ghostwriter, and book coach and the founder of Page & Podium Press. Co-author of the forthcoming Summer of 2020: George Floyd and the Resurgence of the Black Lives Matter Movement, Amanda has authored two nationally award-winning books and ghostwritten many more.

Related Posts

You finished your draft, no what

My Manuscript Is Finished. Now What?

Somehow, the most discouraging part of writing your first book can actually be finishing the first draft. Of course, we want to celebrate that we have finished this manuscript, but at the same time, most new authors have no idea

Sign up for our weekly newsletter to get book-related tips, tricks, and mindset shifts delivered straight to your inbox.

By continuing to browse this website, you agree to our use of cookies to collect website visit statistics.